Adventures in Ice Cream - Part 1

- 3 min read

How it Started

Vanilla ice cream being churned
Churning vanilla ice cream

In my free time, I’ve taken up ice cream making.

I like ice cream. Most people do. What I don’t like is how every commercial ice cream I have readily available to me is flawed in some way.

Häagen-Dazs is too sweet. Ben & Jerry’s is even sweeter. Meiji too. Morinaga is less sweet, but not rich enough. Mingo isn’t even ice cream, it’s ice vegetable fat. I could go on. The only ice cream I think is perfect, that I cannot imagine being improved any further, is Chateraise’s rarely-imported chocolate mint bucky ice cream.

Chateraise's chocolate mint bucky ice cream
The ice cream of the Gods

Anyway, what I’m getting at is that a couple years ago, I bought an ice cream maker, a Cuisinart ICE-21HK, with a grand dream of recreating the chocolate mint ice cream I love so much. I made crappy vanilla ice cream once, following the provided manual, and put it away, disheartened.

The Resurgence

A year later, I retrieved it from its box once more, this time determined to give it a proper go. I did some basic research, using the fantastic free resources available such as dreamscoops.com and icecreamscience.com. I learned about sugar and fat content, milk solids content, overrun (the amount of air in the final product), and more. But still, I delved too greedily, and too deep. I was not prepared for mint chocolate ice cream.

Artificial mint essence tasted horrid. Mint oil was similarly disastrous. Steeping real, fresh mint resulted in a much improved flavour, but the result lacked the icy intensity I’m looking for. I tried using mint liqueurs of various brands, and settled on Get27 being the best. But using enough alcohol for the intensity I wanted caused my ice cream to freeze poorly, and the alcohol kick was too strong.

The chocolate proved to be a challenge of its own as well. Simply melting chocolate and drizzling it in resulted in rock-hard chunks of chocolate. Grating and chopping it gave a better texture, but it was still too hard. I found out about adding oil to soften the frozen chocolate's texture, but by that point I was ready to give up due to the difficulty of getting the mint flavour right to begin with.

So I gave up on mint ice cream, and went back to basics. Vanilla ice cream.

Finding My Own Path

I started by following a popular recipe online. It called for two-thirds of a cup of sugar (~133 grams), 1.5 cups each of milk and cream, a pinch of salt, and 2 entire teaspoons of vanilla extract.

It was awful.

Far too sweet, not enough body, and extremely vanilla-y, too vanilla-y.

I tweaked. Increase the ratio of cream to milk. Cut the sugar in half. Reduce the amount of vanilla extract. Add egg yolks for richness.

But finally, I ended up with a recipe for a rich French-style custard. Here's the recipe, if you're interested.

I recently discovered the Scoopulator ice cream recipe helper via the amazing YouTube channel PolarIceCreamery, and will attempt to use it to refine the recipe further. The first change I have in mind is to replace some of the sugar with dextrose or trehalose, to maintain the low sweetness level while lowering the freezing point so the ice cream is soft and scoopable straight out of the freezer. After that, I might look into adding skimmed milk powder, and stabilisers.

One day, I will get back to attempting to create a satisfactory mint chocolate ice cream. But for now, I will continue to build my knowledge and experience.

← All posts